Saturday, November 21, 2009
Question of the Week
Question for the week of October 16, 2003:

Do you think that a movie like Kill Bill can help whet the American appetite for anime? What did you think of the animation?

complete the form at the bottom of this page to submit your answer
Reader responses:
Anonymous :
Tuesday, October 21, 2003
I am not a huge anime fan, but I absolutely loved this sequence. I don't care what you label it, I found it gorgeous and compelling... easily the best part of the movie. Will it whet our whistle for more? Maybe, but then all it will take is for the American audience to get duped into seeing one of the more rediculous anime films out there and they'd sour on it again.

Anonymous :
Monday, October 20, 2003
Just saw KB yesterday. The animation didn't scream Anime to me, it was more like traced over live-action mixed with a little Plympton. There was just something very un-Anime about it that didn't really excite me at all.

Anonymous :
Saturday, October 18, 2003
That was one of the best, if not the best parts of that movie. At first I had my douts about 2D, but that short part in Kill Bill blew me away. It was so crisp and full of emotion. The only bad part of that movie was how incredibly fake it was, it was almost like a joke at times. But most people in the theater who were not expecting any animation in a Tarantino movie, I think, were pleasantly suprised with how it fit so perfectly.

Anonymous :
Thursday, October 16, 2003
Like most of ProductionIG's work, the animation in Kill Bill was gorgeous, emotional, sleek, and just cool. If you're actually under the misguided impression that "2D" is dead, just look to ProductionIG. While possibly a bit violent for some viewers, you have to consider the context of the film, and the story. It was perfectly suited, and beautifully executed. I hope & believe that American audiences are starting to take note of, and appreciate anime. Kill Bill should help to increase the momentum.

Let us know what you think:

Name, Job Title and Company are optional.

Name:
Job Title:
Company:
Comments:
Spam Verification:

Enter the letters you see above into the box below:

 
Recent Questions of the Week
Since we got word that 20 movies have been submitted to the Academy for Oscar consideration, everyone has been trying to figure out which five will make the nomination list. Which films do you think deserve to be on the ballots in February? The 20 films that have been submitted are • Alvin and the Chipmunks: The SqueakquelAstro BoyBattle for TerraCloudy with a Chance of MeatballsCoralineDisney's A Christmas CarolThe Dolphin – Story of a DreamerFantastic Mr. FoxIce Age: Dawn of the DinosaursMary and MaxThe Missing LynxMonsters vs. Aliens9Planet 51PonyoThe Princess and the FrogThe Secret of KellsTinker Bell and the Lost TreasureA Town Called PanicUp
Fox/Blue Sky’s Ice Age: Dawn of The Dinosaurs set worldwide box-office records by taking in over $878.5 million—and became the most popular animated feature of all time overseas. Why do you think the movie was so successful internationally? Do you think it deserves its mass popularity?
Bugs Bunny recently topped About.com's list of Top Animated Characters of all time, followed by Homer Simpson at No. 2, Mickey Mouse at No. 3, Bart Simpson at No. 4 and Charlie Brown at No. 5. What are your picks for Best Five Toon Characters toons of all time?
We understand that Robert Zemeckis hasn’t been giving any interviews for his upcoming A Christmas Carol movie. What is your take on this new take on the Dickens’ classic? Are you excited to see this performance-capture movie which relies on Jim Carrey’s theatrics or are you going to pass?
Have you sampled any of the new fall season's animated shows? Do you like any of the new toons or do you think the best work is still done by classic favorites such as The Simpsons, Family Guy and South Park?
Question of the Week Archive
Random Questions of the Week
With Sin City open we get another film that blends real actors with digital environments and other CG elements. What do you think of this trend? Did it work for you in Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow?
At the heart of Disney/Pixar's Finding Nemo is the bond between a father and his son, an ironically rare subject for a family film. What other theme(s) do you think should be explored more in animation?
With animated features bigger than ever in terms of box office receipts and studio output, many consider this to be a new golden age for animation. Do you agree, or is there too much disparity between quantity and quality?
Aardman
Animation is currently working on an
Americanized
version of its clay-animated series, Creature Comforts, which will premiere on CBS in midseason. Do you think the show will work on this side of the pond? Will you watch it?
Disney is reportedly developing a 2D-animated feature titled The Frog Princess. Do you think the animation unit can produce a traditional hit with the Pixar team in its corner?